Prayer, Creativity & Faith

For the person who dares to believe differently

One of the most alluring things about Christianity is the feeling of belonging, of being part of something bigger. Of knowing where you fit inside that insular bubble. Of knowing the answers to the fill-in-the-blank questions, knowing what verses to quote, knowing where to find things in the Bible.

And one of the loneliest places in the whole world is when you once fit in those circles but no longer do.

It’s been four years since I left my church of over 20 years. Honestly, I should have seen it coming. I felt the estrangement for years, but I think I was in denial. I was surrounded by people who believed differently, but I spent years trying to wrestle myself back into that space with them.

I eventually left, which helped in some ways (and brought all sorts of other trauma with it). But I’m going to be really vulnerable here and tell you that I’m still struggling.

Because over the years in my evangelical circles, I accumulated literally thousands of—if not friends, then at least social media followers. People would read prayers and articles I posted and connect with me online. I loved it. I thought it was inspiring and sweet, a testament to the power of the Almighty God to connect people.

But now I find myself surrounded by so many people, still, who see the world differently. It’s being expressed in their politics, their Facebook posts, the memes they share (and in full disclosure, my husband, who I love dearly, is also in that same camp). I entrenched myself in those Christian circles, which extended way outside the walls of my old church, and now I feel smothered by it. I am disheartened and saddened by all of it.

So if you are feeling similarly disconnected, I’m writing to you with some affirmation. I am not trying or expecting to change a single person’s mind but to encourage you if you’re feeling separate from the world you love.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

You can be a Christian and still vote for a Democrat.

You can vote differently than your pastor, or your best friend, or even your husband.

You can be against abortion and still vote for the right of a woman to choose (and believe in the possibility of decreasing the number of abortions not through regulations but by providing resources to help those who feel unable to have their babies otherwise, like healthcare and maternity leave).

You don’t have to accept a candidate’s atrocious, harmful, criminal behavior because someone shared a meme that claimed that this man was a sinner just like David. You would not allow someone with his history around your own children. You do not have to put him in the highest office in our land.

You don’t have to endorse behavior that goes against the morality taught to you in church—lying is still wrong. Hatred—and particularly stirring it up in others—is ungodly. Jesus would never support manipulative behavior, violence, rape, egotistical beliefs that one is beyond censure, or a blatant disregard for everything else he taught.

Your faith beliefs don’t have to be imposed on everyone else in order for you to be true to God; didn’t God give us ample opportunities to choose his way, with a free heart? True belief has never been about laws and regulations. God has called us to certain behaviors and standards, but at the deepest level he wants a heart change, not blind followers.

You don’t have to vote Republican to show your love for this country. Republicans do not own the American flag, and Democrats can believe in our Constitution. You don’t have to accept a candidate that has shown every sign that he will dismantle it all.

You don’t have to believe the misinformation people share. When something seems ridiculous, shocking, over the top, consider that maybe it was manufactured to elicit outrage. (For instance, Democrats do not support murdering babies that have been born, no matter how many times people claim otherwise.) Media outlets can put their own spin on things, so don’t just read the one you are used to. Read others too. Look for sources reporting the actual quotes, events, or whatnot, and decide for yourself. Often the things that are the most shocking are simply distorted claims about the facts.

You don’t have to defend one person’s behavior by bashing the other. There are unflattering things on both sides. It’s my opinion that the behavior of one side is potentially way more harmful to me, my children, and this world than the other, but I know most of those on the opposite side believe the same about my side, and think I’m completely deceived and misguided, too. And that’s something to remember:

A person’s political choices don’t necessarily indicate their character. I keep telling myself this. Some people close to me strongly disagree with this, and perhaps I’m being naive. It is so difficult to separate a person’s character from the views they support. Sometimes I do think it says a lot about a person to see what they will overlook or ignore, to see what they say they stand for. It boggles my mind. I cannot fathom the levels of support and the twisted logic some people share. But my husband and I are way apart politically and I know, know, know he is a good man.

And, lastly, you don’t have to tell a single person who you vote for.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

I’m sure I will officially lose hundreds of my readers now; this is such a loaded and divisive topic. But if you’re reading this far in spite of disagreeing with me, thank you for giving me the benefit of the doubt enough to listen. I’m grateful, and sure, I wish I could convince you to change your mind, but I know I can’t. Besides, you are not my primary audience for this.

I’m writing this because it is incredibly lonely to see the world differently than those you love, and if that is you, I want you to know you’re not alone. I’m also writing for myself, as one of those who feels sad, discouraged, distraught, and very alone.

I’m watching the way the nonbelievers look at the loudest among us who profess Christianity, and I watch what doesn’t to me look like godly behavior, and I grieve for the state of the church. I want to remain true to what Christianity was meant to be, but I have a strong reluctance to be categorized as a Christian. What used to be a spiritual movement seems to have become instead a political movement. The priorities have flip-flopped. I want to speak out, defend the faith, defend the Church. But the Church has changed, and in spite of the depths of my faith, I often wonder if there is a place there for me any longer.

The way someone else practices their faith does not have to change my own faith. Nor does it have to change yours. But it’s naive to think it has no impact, which is why I’m so deeply sad. I’m seeing families and friendships being torn apart and I feel helpless to stop it. I draw some comfort from spending time with likeminded friends, but it’s hard not to feel like the world is out to get you. It’s hard to think that maybe this political stuff isn’t in fact as dire as it feels, because while that’s possible, it’s also possible that the consequences are more dire than we even imagine.

I’ve done all that I can do. Now, it’s in God’s hands: the election, the state of this country, the damaged relationships and broken spirits.

One of the deepest ironies of this season has been reading the prayers shared by those I vehemently disagree with politically—because we all want the same thing. To follow the will of God. We long for people to see the abundant goodness of God’s love. We pray for safety, and protection. For unity over division. To live in a state of peace and not one of strife.

Lord, help us to find our way. Help us to reimagine a country—and world—not divided by hatred but united in love. Protect us, guide us, be with us. In the most holy name of Jesus I pray. Amen.

23 Responses to “For the person who dares to believe differently”

  1. Dr Lynn Schriner says:

    Dearest soul sister
    I just read this to my husband who Thank God is aligned with me on the election. I cannot imagine how you are able to continue in your “marriage as you have known it to be” after all that has occured. My heart feels sorrow with yours as I have lost many many dear ones who I feel I no longer know. You perfectly described leaving the Church as I too tried to fit myself into their (how to say it) what I felt often was “The Church lady way” or the “way we worship way.” I was a leader in some of those churches and they broke my heart with their judgment of me and the way God was using me in worship or leading a young man weeping in the pew to Jesus. I was admonished for it because “aa woman should not lead a man to Christ.” I was told after teaching womens Bible study and sharing my testimony (we were studying women of the Bible) that “We do not believe in tongues, you do not fit in here and we think it is better for you to leave.” The Sunday before I had gone to my knees and raised my hands while singing a solo. They were shocked and had asked me to never do that again. That my job was to “lead the people not worship God that way.” I could go on and on, I share because it breaks my heart to write this, breaks my heart to read this, breaks my heart to know this.
    I also thank you so very very much for this amazing post. I am very grateful for you and your vulnerability and your heart and your love.
    I truly believe everything you said. Everything. Thank you for being my voice too.
    Love in Jesus our Lord
    Lynn

  2. Judy says:

    Thanks for sharing this. It reflects so many of my thoughts and feelings as I grew up in a church similar to the one you were in. It took a long time for me to realize that there were others who had similar misgivings to the ones that I had. I am thankful that I am now in a church which encourages me to think, ask questions, study, and recognize that God loves everyone.

  3. Warren Rush says:

    Thank you Kelly for addressing the same feeling I have had since 2020. I have drifted away from today’s Christianity that I was used to. Politics was never an issue until the 8-10 years. You truly address how I feel now. Why do so many people who claim to be Christians believe in lies when truth is right before them. Who support people that really are not striving to be like Jesus.
    So called leaders in our government who push totally non-Christian ideas. I worry about the Christian National movement.
    The idea is to bring more people into Christianity and not push them away. Thanks for addressing,Kelly!

  4. Sheree king says:

    I think we need to watch out that our sources are accurate and we absolutely need to be praying, praying, praying. As a Christian who has had a faith for 40 years, I look at the values that we believe in and that’s why I see what God is going through Trump right now. If God could use a donkey in Numbers 22:21-35, then he can use Trump. My prayer is for the Republicans to win. This man right now, has changed so much and is being used by God. Kamala Harris is the total opposite.

    • Kelly O'Dell Stanley says:

      I guess what I would say to that is if God can use someone like DT, then why couldn’t he also use Kamala? She is not blatantly living in disregard to every moral compass we have as he appears to be. I will never understand those who think he is somehow specially anointed. We’re taught in church that when we are seeking God, we will bear fruit in our lives, and what I see from him is pretty rotten. If someone is voting Republican because of a single issue (and for many Christians that is to vote against the right for a woman to have autonomy over her body), I can understand that, but I don’t get taking that to the next step of claiming God is using him. But clearly you and I disagree, and that’s okay. Thanks for reading this anyway.

  5. Crystal Kottlowski says:

    I cannot begin to tell you how much I love this! I had a couple of thoughts as I moved through this. Did you know that Some churches believe Gods grace is big enough for everyone? I’m blessed that I have found a church on Sundays that when I look around my family during service I see LGBTQ+ families, “traditional” families, mixed families, families w/ disabilities, families of all shapes, sizes, and political beliefs. Finding a church whose core belief works from Gods grace, is a game changer. When I hear the rhetoric I always go to a place of seeking to learn, listening, and remembering that Those that are last among us are first to Him. Thank you for sharing!

    • Kelly O'Dell Stanley says:

      Crystal, I have found one such church, but it’s what I see going on outside of that, among other professed Christians, that is so troubling! Thanks for commenting!

  6. Joel Shaffer says:

    The circles that I am part of include many pro-life democrats, many of whom are in the Black Protestant tradition. Pro-life for them (and myself) is whole-life from “the womb to the tomb.” Therefore, issues such as healthcare, poverty, and housing (we are currently in the worst housing crisis in America since the end of WW2) are pro-life issues because the majority of women with unplanned pregnancies among the working class and poor who end up with abortions would rather have kept their baby if they had a stronger safety net like healthcare or stable housing. If you haven’t read it, Ben Watson’s “The New Fight for Life: Roe, Race, and a Pro-Life Commitment to Justice” is a must-read.

    Also, you might find some commonality with the And Campaign. Even though I just discovered your Facebook and webpage, what you seem to desire among Christians and political discourse is happening among the And Campaign folks. https://andcampaign.org/

  7. Connie says:

    Jesus was a radical liberal for his time. The fact that so many people, who call themselves Christians,spew such hate about liberalism is chilling

    It also floors me that they emphatically state that they can’t legislate gun safety but they do think they can legislate pregnancy and actually stop abortion. Why is it a woman has to surrender her entire body to save the life of a fetus but the people who decree that don’t need to donate blood to save a life, or give up part of their liver… nor are they required to be an organ donor once they die, and we all know those are things that actually save lives..

    The pro life party also talks at every other initiative that would save lives. Raising the minimum wage to a livable level, universal health care, low income housing, programs that provide basic income, WIC, headstart, affordable child care… all would do so much more to save lives. It really feels like they just want babies born and they stop caring about them.

    Anyway, enough of my soap box.. the more you talk about liberal issues, the more people start questioning.. and that is important even if you feel like you’re on the outside

    • Kelly O'Dell Stanley says:

      Yes, I think there are so many contradictions – and so many other things that would help achieve the outcomes people profess to want. It’s reassuring to know others think similarly!

  8. Deb Ramey says:

    Kelly, I am Rob Ramey’s stepmom and Teresa Ramey was my best friend. (Just wanted to explain who I am.) Truly have enjoyed getting to know your writing and the Italian adventure really spoke to me. We have been fortunate to travel to the UK and Europe frequently in the last 10 years (late in life because of work) and loved Italy. But France has my heart. I simply would like to add an opinion or two to your thoughts on this election. First, I think we have allowed ourselves to get far too invested in elections. I’m old, so I remember my parents voting for Nixon when Kennedy won and they went on with their lives. They also stopped living for 5 days when he was killed, and wept with the rest of the nation. Horrible times – the 60’s. The country is still here and thriving. An election is simply a transaction that occurs every 4 years and somehow we figure it out. Second, I was a firm, hardened NeverTrumper in 2016, as a Republican. I wrote in Paul Ryan that year and watched in amazement as Trump won on election night. I was critical from day one. Slowly I noticed that his administration was doing things differently, and that they were incredibly open with the press and the people. To make it short, it was a 4 years filled with tremendous accomplishments: USMCA, Abraham Accords, historic middle class tax reform, First Step Act, criminal justice reform, elimination of tons of regulations,secured the southern border, installed three strict constitutionalist Supreme Court justices, Space Force, the elimination of ISIS, the elimination of Solemeini, record job growth, involved the US in no new wars and fostered peace around the world. These are the reasons I voted to rehire Trump as chief executive. The last 4 years have not been successful years for our country, or for the world. The presence of major conflicts and the deaths of thousands upon thousands of innocents around the world is my number one reason for rehiring him. Putin would have never invaded Ukraine. Hamas would have never massacred Israelis. Iran would not now threaten the entire mideast with nuclear war, NK would be silent, Xi would not be threatening Taiwan. Second, over 21 million illegal aliens have either walked or been flown into this country by the Biden administration. Our small towns are coming apart at the seams, and crime can not be ignored. We have murderers walking among us, people here who will do us harm, military age men who should be defending their own countries, not living illegally in ours. I’m going to stop here, except to add one thing. I am pro-choice, and am sickened that the left is finding joy is advocating for abortion, yelling about it as if it were something to champion. It’s not. It should be approached somberly, seriously, cautiously, respectfully. It should not be a reason to elect a president. No rights have been eliminated. These rights belong to the states because we are a constitutional republic. I simply wanted to add my thoughts to your thoughtful essay.

    • Kelly O'Dell Stanley says:

      Hi Deb. Of course I know who you are. I appreciate any kind of open dialog as long as it’s respectful. And yet my view of the things that you mention is very different. Many of the things you celebrate are things I grieve. I am concerned by the way DT aligns himself with fascists/dictators and the countries he encourages to meddle in the US. Tons of people who worked closely with him have come out against him, declaring him unstable and dangerous. I think the comments/statistics you shared about the immigrants – and the characterization of how they get here, what they’re given by our country, and the dangers they provide – are patently not true.

      To be clear, I do not rejoice in abortion, and I don’t think many do. I think it’s an incredibly complex and personal decision, and I think many people take it very seriously but feel they have no choice because of life circumstances making it impossible to adequately provide for themselves and their families, which is why I think we need to make having a baby possible for all people through having helpful protections for time off work and healthcare and daycare and more. The reason I believe the protections need to be at a federal level is because of what we’ve already seen happen. Rights people once had have been taken away. In my mind, the federal government should set standards for freedoms and protections across the whole country, not just for the people lucky enough to live in a community of people who think like they do. If we’re the land of the free, we can’t have more regulations on our bodies than we do on our guns, just to name one thing.

      Thanks for commenting.

  9. Deb Ramey says:

    Kelly, I would like you to do a bit more research on the illegal immigration issue. The numbers are not being reported by most of the usual media outlets as they will not report anything that could be construed as negative to this administration. It is an issue that is truly going to be a challenge for this country over the next decade and longer. These are not asylum seekers. The federal government has flown in over 500,000 people from Haiti, Venezuela etc. Many have been placed by the thousands in small towns in Ohio and Indiana. As for foreign policy, one would think that peace is preferred to war, so it has been surprising to see the Democratic Party go all out for war. And that is what has happened. US weakness makes the world vulnerable. A strong US is a peacekeeper. Please take a closer look at this issue as well.

    • Kelly O'Dell Stanley says:

      Deb, I want to be respectful, so let me just say that you can’t assume someone has not done their research just because their conclusion is different from yours. I have done my research, and I don’t believe in conspiracy theories or “facts” that can’t be found in mainstream media. I believe that many of those “facts” are rhetoric and manipulation designed by conservatives to instill fear in others to get them united against a common “enemy.” One of the biggest issues I think we have in this country is that no one can agree on what is truth. Without that common ground, it’s hard to make any headway in a discussion. If I believed the facts were as you see them, I might come to the same conclusions as you, but the sources I trust say otherwise. I don’t accept things blindly, I promise, even though I come to different conclusions than you do. I don’t want to keep going back and forth – we’re not going to change each other’s minds, so best not to go there.

  10. Toni E. says:

    Just a short reply that I fully understand and relate with you. Glad I’m not alone. My husband is even a Republican but not voting for Trump thankfully. My church is kind of 50/50 which in the end makes me happy but distances him. My prayer is you feel the many other people in your same shoes. Amen.

  11. Mark says:

    However, if you choose a candidate whose response to “Jesus is LORD” is “You’re at the wrong rally”, then I really don’t want to hear any so-called moral high ground

    • Kelly O'Dell Stanley says:

      There were other things said at the same time and I believe she was responding to the anti-choice statements, not the “Jesus is Lord”
      Comment. It is very unclear even on the recordings. I think it’s another case of Christians twisting a situation to justify their position but I don’t believe she’s anti-Christian. A person doesn’t have to be a Christian be our president – clearly, since so many support the republican candidate. Even so, Harris is a Christian. From a CNN Town Hall reporter on CBS:

      At a CNN town hall on Wednesday night, Harris highlighted her faith, saying she prays “every day, sometimes twice a day.”

      “I was raised to believe in a loving God, to believe that your faith is a verb,” Harris said. “You know, you live your faith. And that, that the way that one should do that is that your work and your life’s work should be to think about how you can serve in a way, uplifting other people. ”

      She said one of the first phone calls she made after President Biden told her was dropping out of the presidential race was to her pastor. She said she “needed that spiritual kind of connection.”

  12. Shelley Thomas says:

    Yes! You said it soooo well!

  13. Stephanie says:

    Thank you, Kelly. This is a very important and meaningful post for so many. I continue to follow you after you interviewed me so many years ago and appreciate the work you do.

  14. Wendy Muse says:

    I’m not even sure I know how and what I want to say. I’ve been sad and hopeful in reading your posts.
    I love you Kelly and I love the Lord and I love the church. I believe you love big and your heart is in the right place. I’m sad to hear you don’t feel apart of the church.
    Praise God, He already knows how this election will turn out and can use either candidate and either/both parties.
    I think our preacher said it so well in the begin of our current series Thrones and Thornes. Both candidates are liars and there is no good candidate. If our hope is in the election we will be let down. Our only hope is Jesus.
    I agree, in one of your posts you and others are saying similar things about your beliefs and disagree on facts.
    I feel so much coming out of both camps and the media is just sad, finger pointing and manipulating. I feel like it’s so hard to talk about facts and get to the real truth on any and most issues because there’s so much reaction/reactive and “but your candidate” that we all hear and there’s so much back and forth.
    None of this makes me love my sisters of the faith or you or others any less. All the hate spewing on both sides just makes me really sad. I agree we won’t all agree and will continue to have different opinions. Thats how God made us. I’m sad that all this is causing so much division when this broken world needs revival in our churches, in our homes and in our communities. I’m grateful there is a God and He is in control. I’m grateful He knows my heart and knows that just because I may see the facts differently and my opinions are different than yours, He knows that I do love you and others and my heart is breaking. I’ll be praying because that’s all I know to do and I know I can’t only He can
    I hope my rambling makes some sense to you and you hear, you are not alone and you are loved. God sees you and He sees all this and praise God, no matter how this election turns out He will still be in control and use either candidate for good and His glory (in His way and His timing, which unfortunately none of us may understand on this side of eternity).

Leave a Reply